History is All You Left Me Book Review

120ec826-3202-45a3-80fa-a21783cb86b4-7101-00000bc96ec37bea_tmp

3/5 Stars

LGBTQIA YA Contemporary

So here we go.

Once again, I had high hopes for Adam Silvera because of how everyone talks him up and says his books are their absolute favorite thing ever. So I was fairly looking forward to reading his new book when it came out, but I ended being really, really underwhelmed. Just like… oh okay. I guess that really was the story and the whole book. Which really sucks because I thought I was going to be so in love with this book and scream my love for it from the rooftops. Yeah, not so much.

This book deals well with the topic of grief. I can’t imagine Silvera could have done a better job having Griffin mourn Theo. It is realistic and believable. I wasn’t like thinking anything bad about the main aspect of the book at all. I liked even better how Silvera has the ability to write the grief in such a way it reminds me of my own loss. He was spot on with the important aspect. Not to mention, I love how he writes books more teens and people should be reading. We need more LGBTQIA perspectives in YA novels and just books in general. Kudos to Silvera for doing it so well. But….

I didn’t like this book a lot. I had a hard time getting through the book because of Griffin. He is just such a toxic character. He makes bad choices and doesn’t care about who he hurts. He wants to feel better about dealing with the loss of his first love so he decides to connect with his dead ex boyfriend’s current boyfriend. What could possibly go wrong at all with the situation? Not to mention the time shifts in the book from the current to the past. This means you’re only getting one part of the story. Obviously something is being left out and it’s going to be important. Silvera always does that with his books. You find out later he purposefully kept out a piece of information meant to blow your mind. Of course, he did it once again with this book. Maybe it’s just his thing, but it’s not one of my favorite literary plot devices.

The secret bit of information you find out left me confused. I didn’t see it coming, and I don’t know how it fit into the story. The whole story was about Griffin and Jackson trying to deal with Theo dying and boom, there’s this other tidbit you find out which shifts the story once again. I kind of lost interest in this book because it was dragging a lot. I just wanted to find out the ending. So I forced myself to push through. I once again just went oh okay to this big plot reveal and kind of read through how it tied it to the rest of the story. So, yeah. I ended up being really underwhelmed. And I don’t know why, but I felt like the depiction of the OCD and mental illness seems a tad inaccurate. I don’t want to say I don’t want to read Silvera ever again because it’s so great to have a voice in books dealing with LGBTQIA characters, but I’m hoping he tries something new with his writing eventually so I don’t keep on getting annoyed at his constant utilization of certain writing tools. This book tackles grief well. I just hated the main character and pretty much everything else. Oops.

Advertisements

One thought on “History is All You Left Me Book Review

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s